For performance/cost, the Q Industries MV50 (same as the Masterflow MF-1050) seems to be the way to go even though it is generally $60-$70 anymore. For what you are talking about, I would go that route.
For higher quality, but much more expensive, Viair has some very good options (88P up to 33" tires, $70; 300P=33" tires, $120; 400P=35"tires, $190). They have good data on their website unlike the others. This is what I am planning on since I am leery of the MV50, which has generally good reviews, but enough that say "it died the first/second time I used it".
For higher speed at lower cost the Smittybilt can't be beat, but is fairly new and I wouldn't expect much better build quality than the MV50. I haven't found any good long term reviews of it yet. If you are only filling one tire at a time it doesn't seem like this would be necessary.