Consider the Hankook Danapro ATM
I have 40k on mine and they are still above the fifty percent mark left on the tires....
Several thousand of those miles have been in nasty winter crap up here in Idaho.
They dont even plow the roads near my house unless we get over six inches....
when I lived further north near AB I was several miles from the nearest county paved road.
that meant sometimes I was pushing through ten inches of fresh snow on top of several inches of wet slushy crap underneath
Have had them down close to 2 thousand miles of gravel hold up very well, not super awesome in deep mud
they are reviewed well for snow and if you look at the tread pattern between these and Hankooks winter/snow tire there is not much difference.
They are lacking compared to a studded tire on Glare ice, but then most things are.
I went with the 10 ply for my tacoma and have been impressed compared to the dura track , KM2, stt, BFG general grabber AT2, all of which I have run in the winter.
I will most likely put a set of studded winters on next year and roatate these out for another few years.
At the price point, they can't be beat.