I went with the FJ because I've wanted one for years. I could have purchased a new 4R but like you, I felt it was a little cramped. Just too narrow for me as I have broad shoulders. The FJ, while it technically has a little less cargo room in back, felt much more roomy and spacious. The biggest issue I have with it from the factory is the tiny gas tank. I wish they offered more of them in the US with the optional auxiliary gas tank. But nothing some Jerry cans or rotopax cant solve I suppose! And you're right about resale. I was looking to other day and I'm pretty sure I could sell mine right now for almost exactly what I bought it for. And it has about 20,000 more miles than when I first bought it. That's pretty good resale!