I've been very impressed with the Rayovac Sportsman Extreme:
- 300 lumen out put
- 72 hr run time on high, 150 hr run time on low
- Only three D cell batteries
- Compact size (A little bigger than a can of soda in all dimensions)
- Nicely profiled carry handle that folds out of the way
- Very rugged construction with dense polymer and rubber on base
- Removable outer lens
- Hook on bottom so it can be hung upside down
I had a couple of the CFL 4-D cell based camping lanters but I wanted something with more run time that I didn't need to worry about at the campsite. Turns out the Rayovac unit is spot on. It looks to be about 40-50% brighter than my old lanters, takes 25% fewer batteries (3 Ds instead of 4 Ds), and runs about 5x as long on full bright. Oh, and it'll run almost 10x as long on dim. Something the CFL-based lights can't do (dim, that is). And it's smaller and more compact.
I figure if I'm running the light non-stop for 4 hrs a day (8pm to mid-night?) it'll last me 18 days straight of solid camping. AT that rate, one set of batteries will probably last me 2 years, at least. I like to go camping but it's usually on a couple days at a time and only a few times per year.
Anyways, color me VERY impressed.
Oh, and it's ~$25 at Amazon.
I ended up buying Coleman's lantern stand to go with it as my campsite lighting system. The lantern does an awesome job of pumping out the light. And the stand does an awesome job of getting the lantern up high enough so it'll broadcast that light around the campsite. I view them as a system for my purposes.
This is the Rayovac hung upside down on the Colman lantern stand.
The outer lens has been removed and set on the ottoman to the right.
Without the lens it's a little brighter.
The lantern stand folds up to about the same length as a folding chair but slightly slimmer. Cost is ~$30 and it's built pretty well. Alternatively, for about the same cost one could make their own lantern stand out of 7ft or 9ft photographer's lighting stands. Just get a metal bar with a hole drilled in on end and bend up the other end to hang the lantern.